the Ogallala Bay Rum aftershave website homepage

The Genuine Ogallala Bay Rum Toiletry Company is one of the world’s most respected producers of bay rum products. Originally founded in the 1870s in Ogallala, Nebraska, this company has a long history of turning dirty Cowboys into proper gentlemen. One of Ogallala’s biggest sellers is the Ogallala Bay Rum Aftershave.

This soothing combination of oils and alcohol is supposed to transport you to the tropical Caribbean islands. Anyone who’s thinking about ordering this product should read on. This review will tell you the good and the bad about this extremely popular bay rum aftershave.

Editor’s Pick: Ogallala Bay Rum Aftershave

Ogallala Bay Rum Features

The Ogallala Bay Rum Aftershave comes in a sleek blue glass bottle with a black screw top. The best-selling aftershave size on the market is eight ounces. Every Ogallala Bay Rum Aftershave is made with the following ingredients: bay rum fragrance oil, witch hazel, purified water, and alcohol.

The Ogallala Bay Rum Company also sells various aftershaves infused with other oils as well as a cologne. Most of these products are around the same price as the original aftershave. The most popular flavored aftershave is sandalwood, but there are also peppercorn and cedar & sage aftershaves.

Pros of Ogallala Bay Rum

1: Vintage Label & Original Bottle Design

First off, the packaging of this product is exceptional. You can tell the Ogallala team took a great deal of time figuring out the best possible bottle design to give that old-timey vibe. The vintage label design will transport you to an age where cowboys roamed the Texan countryside and every town had a barbershop just for men. You’ll feel as if you’re grabbing an aftershave right out of a Wild West apothecary cellar every time you shave.

2: Organic Bay Rum Close Scent

Anyone looking for a strong bay rum clove scent will love this product. Although Ogallala infuses other oils to add more complexity to their blends, the bay rum definitely stands out. Even better, you won’t find any chemicals made in a lab or names you can’t pronounce on this label. All that you’ll find in this baby are good, fresh, organic oils, herbs, and alcohol. Men who consider themselves bay rum connoisseurs must try this product at least once.

3: It Is Worth The Price

The price for an Ogallala Bay Rum Aftershave isn’t outrageous considering the product’s quality. All of Ogallala’s ingredients are all-natural and their product design is extremely professional. Basically, you get what you paid for here. While it might not be the “cheapest” on the market, it’s also not overpriced.

4: Contains Alcohol

Since this product has a good amount of alcohol in it, expect a powerful burn in your aftershave. Men who like the feel of a burn will love how this aftershave feels on their skin once they’re done shaving.

5: Top Notch Customer Support Service

Many customers say the customer service department at Ogallala is top-notch. Anyone who has issues with their aftershave is more than welcome to send Ogallala an email or give them a call. Some customers said they received full refunds and even a few free products just for making a tiny complaint. Although we can’t guarantee Ogallala will give you these things, it’s nice to know their customer service team has good reviews online.

a bottle of Ogallala Bay Rum aftershave

Cons of Ogallala Bay Rum

1: The Scent Fades Away Quickly

Some men who use Ogallala Bay Rum Aftershave complain that the scent fades too quickly. This could be good news or bad news depending on what you’re looking for. If you live with someone who can’t stand the smell of aftershave, or if you work in an environment where people have allergies, this might be a plus. For those looking for an aftershave with a bit more staying power, however, this might not be the best product.

2: A Screw-Top Bottle/No Dabber

As mentioned above, this bottle comes with a screw top. There’s no dabber here, so you have to be careful pouring this aftershave out onto a cotton ball. You could easily tip this bottle over and pour out way too much liquid.

3: Risk of The Screw Top Getting Stuck

A few people have had problems with twisting the screw top too far and being unable to open the bottle again. Again, you have to be really careful with this product’s top. If this is giving you too many problems, Ogallala does sell a more authentic apothecary bottle separately on its main website.

4: Burning Sensation – Alcohol Content

There is a good deal of alcohol in this aftershave, so be prepared to “feel the burn.” Shaving experts tend to recommend using balms instead of alcohol-based aftershaves, especially if you have sensitive skin. As you probably already know, alcohol dries out the skin, which isn’t particularly good for people who have dry skin, to begin with.

Is Ogallala Bay Rum Worth Buying?

If you like bay rum, you’ll like this aftershave. Everything in Ogallala’s product is true to an authentic bay rum mixture and is made with all-natural ingredients. The price point, while not cheap, isn’t terribly expensive. Plus, the packaging design will make you feel like you’ve stepped back into an old-fashioned American barbershop. At the end of the day, men looking for an authentic bay rum aftershave should seriously consider buying the Ogallala Bay Rum Aftershave.

By the way, Ogallala does sell a sampler pack called the Bonanza Sampler. In addition to the regular Bay Rum Aftershave, you also get to try the company’s Cologne, Bay Rum, and Peppercorns Aftershave, Bay Rum Sage & Cedar Aftershave, and Bay Rum and Sandalwood Aftershave. All the bottles in this set are two ounces each and made of plastic. You can find this sampler pack for around $23 online, so it’s not a bad deal if you want to give Ogallala a full trial.

Bottom Line

When you’re researching bay rum aftershaves, you’re bound to come across Ogallala Bay Rum. Ogallala is one of the most popular and highly reviewed bay rum brands in the shaving industry. This is a great bay rum aftershave to try whether you’re an expert or a total newbie.

Even if you don’t like Ogallala’s scent, you have to admit that it’s authentic and true to the bay rum recipe. Also, if you don’t like this product, you’ll only be out around $23. So, anyone in the market for that old-timey barbershop feel, give Ogallala Bay Rum a try. What’ve you got to lose?

Image sources: Ogallala Website, Amazon

Last update on 2022-09-30 at 02:18 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API